Yomawari: The Long Night Collection (PS5) Review – Charming and Cruel

Prepare to be heartbroken.

Published:

Despite my overwhelming love of the horror genre, there is one subgenre that has largely served as a blind spot for me: J-horror. The concept of a Japanese take on some of the core horror tropes, complete with a unique cultural spin on the setting and monsters, has existed in popular media for decades. Yet, I have only really experienced Silent Hill f and Fatal Frame, and despite my love of both, I have not really had the push to check out other games within the subgenre. So, when given the chance to experience the underrated Yomawari franchise, I was unsure about what to expect. 

Yomawari: The Long Night Collection is a compilation of the first two entries in the J-horror series: Night Alone and Midnight Shadows. Despite the original games releasing on PlayStation Vita in 2016/2017, and the collection first debuting on Nintendo Switch in 2018, this is the first time I have ever even heard of the series. Going in to the newly released PlayStation 5 version, I had absolutely no idea what kind of experience I was in for. Would this be a relatively docile horror experience as indicated by the art style, or would this turn out to be deeply haunting in its tone? As it turned out, both games fit neatly into the latter, as Yomawari managed to provide a horror experience that I am still thinking about even now, for better and for worse. 

Night Alone

Yomawari Night Alone Intro

When I first booted up the collection, I figured it make sense to appreciate the games one-by-one. After all this is not exactly a remaster or a remake of some classic horror games lost to time—instead, it is a port of two games that are still playable today on other platforms. As such, there are no additional features added specifically for the new collection. The selling point of The Long Night Collection are the games included, starting with 2016’s Night Alone. Night Alone opens with an unnamed little girl walking her dog Poro, when a tragic incident suddenly occurs. She is reluctant to inform her sister about what happened, so her sister runs into the night to find their dog and bring him home. Now, the protagonist must venture out to find both her sister and her dog, all while overcoming the dangers of her hometown, which has been overrun with ghosts. 

Night Alone completely blindsided me in the first few minutes with just how brutal its opening is. While most horror games ease you into the tension, all of the Yomawari games are alike in how they immediately assault the player with extremely heavy subject matters right from the outset. On the one hand, I admire the choice to jump straight into the horror and make it abundantly clear that this game is not for the faint of heart. On the other hand, it does present an issue in regards to pacing. When you open with the most horrifying scene in the game, the rest of the story is left with the impossible task of maintaining that brutality. Still, while future entries struggle with that task quite a bit, Night Alone managed to keep me compelled from start to finish thanks to its horror and mechanics. 

Yomawari Night Alone Horror

The monsters of Night Alone are quite terrifying, to say the least. A lot of them are pretty run of the mill spirits, some of which have some really odd designs, but their terror comes from how they highlight its gameplay systems. Throughout most of Night Alone, you will be exploring the world around you in order to find further clues about your sister’s location. The “open world” functions similarly to the Silent Hill franchise and Fatal Frame, in that you can largely go anywhere you want, but certain areas are locked until you progress the story. Of course, much like those games, the world around you is infested with plenty of terrifying monsters. 

For example, in the late game you are locked in a distant factory by a mysterious spirit. While you can usually use Jizo Statues to save and fast travel, the fast travel option has been completely removed as an option. As such, you have to blindly wander around the area in order to find a way to escape. Along your journey, you will encounter ghosts that advance towards you if you look away, and stop if you look right at them. On their own, these monsters are relatively harmless if you know how to deal with them. However, when combined with a monster simply known as Meat that relentlessly chases you every few minutes, my heart was constantly in my throat throughout every second I spent exploring the Factory. 

Yomawari Night Alone Factory

So much of Night Alone is spent panicking as you face increasingly more terrifying monsters. From ghost girls to sentient tires, there are all sorts of dangers standing between you and your sister. For the most part, the game is able to balance jumpscares with a tense atmosphere, to the point that when it managed to get a genuine shriek of terror from me, it felt earned rather than cheap. That said, the world of Night Alone is massive, and at times, its hard to figure out where to go. I spent so much time wandering around in random directions that I often felt more aimless than scared. Easily, though, the most engaging part of Yomawari: Night Alone is its presentation.

The choice to adapts its core characters and even the ghosts in a somewhat cutesy style gives the game a distinct look that not many horror games possess. It also made the more violent sequences all the more devastating. Its one thing to watch a little girl almost die in a realistic art style, but something about the chibi-esque visuals made those near-death experiences even more unnerving. There were quite a few moments where my heart was borderline aching, not just because of the horror, but because I could not stand the thought that these adorable and charming characters could be hurt in anyway.

Overall, even if there were parts of Night Alone‘s gameplay I did not connect with, the presentation and horror elements were more than enough to keep me hooked on the story up until the end. After my enjoyment of Night Alone, I was really curious to see how Midnight Shadows shaped up. Surprisingly, it is even better than its predecessor, despite being largely the same game but with different characters and a far darker tone. 

Midnight Shadows

Yomowari: Midnight Shadows Opening

After the opening of Night Alone, I thought the series would never be able to live up to that level of darkness in future entries. Midnight Shadows immediately proved me wrong, as its tone is somehow even more bleak. This time, you play as two characters: Yui and Haru. Both are elementary school students, though the latter is about to move away to a new home. The former is clearly affected by this distance, but before she can express her feelings, a mysterious spirit abducts Yui. As Yui, you must try to find your way out of increasingly dire situations in order to escape and get home. As Haru, you must retrace Yui’s steps and reunite with your best friend by any means necessary. 

Admittedly, I am somewhat conflicted on Midnight Shadows‘ premise. The reason for my complicated feelings stems from the game’s use of heavy subject matter. At first, these grim scenes felt more like they were being used for shock value rather than being a meaningful source of terror. This is especially prevalent in how the general premise is largely similar to its predecessor. Both start with a young girl going through a traumatic event and have a plot twist revolving around the fate of a core character. While Night Alone‘s opening shocked me, Midnight Shadows felt somewhat cheap by comparison as I had just seen an opening that was fairly similar. As such, it made it pretty easy to predict how the story was going to come to an end. 

Yomawari: Midnight Shadows Story

However, Midnight Shadows more than makes up for the predictable narrative with better characters and gameplay. Yui and Haru are far more compelling than the protagonists of the prior entry (partly because they have actual names this time around). Their dynamic feels very real, and even if you don’t know how they met, you can just feel their bond in the sequences where they talk about each other from afar. It made me all the more invested in reuniting the two. Furthermore, while the conclusion is somewhat bittersweet, the deeper themes of mental health and suicide are very well handled. The way the gameplay manages to capture the sensation of having intrusive thoughts while depressed is not only relatable, but creatively brilliant. 

Speaking of gameplay, for the most part its very similar to Night Alone. You still are thrust into a pretty expansive world overrun with ghosts, with there even being some areas and monsters that look fairly identical to the setting of Midnight Shadows‘ predecessor. While these moments were a tad distracting, the overall improvements to the gameplay formula offset my concerns. The most notable is the pacing. The flow of Midnight Shadows is far better in how there is a very clear sense of where you are meant to go at all times. For instance, you will play as Yui in a section with a lot of books. When you switch to Haru, then, you know then that the library marker on the map is where you need to go. It makes the sense of progression far more satisfying as you move from point A to point B. 

Yomawari: Midnight Shadows Charms

One major new mechanic are charms that you get at the end of each story chapter. These add perks to your gameplay to better suit your playstyle. For instance, if you find yourself running out of a lot of coins, which are used to save at Jizo Statues, you can equip a charm that makes coins a more abundant resource. The one that I used the most increased the amount of time in which I could sprint, which made it way easier to evade the many ghosts that roam the town. These charms never felt like they offset the game’s balance and inherent difficulty. Even with the ability to move faster, I was still getting caught by monsters the moment I made a poor decision in the midst of gameplay. 

Similarly to Night Alone, the presentation of Midnight Shadows is its greatest strength. Once again, I found it way easier to fall in love with each character due to their charming designs. In addition, the game does a far better job of immediately scaling up the horror when it needs to. Some of the game’s “antagonists” look like they are from a different game entirely with how creepy their designs are. So, even if the game was a bit more predictable than Night Alone, the stronger character writing and gameplay made Midnight Shadows a far better game. Furthermore, both Yomawari games combined serve as pretty good horror experiences for those who love the J-horror genre.

The Long Night

Yomowari: Midnight Shadows Horror

What is the goal of horror? Is it to unsettle you with terrifying circumstances and unnerving monsters, all to make you want to look away in fear? Or is it to take advantage of your sense of empathy and present you with a true sense of despair at the sight of endless suffering and agony? I have come to realize that the latter is something J-horror in particular specializes in, and Yomawari embodies it. It may not be for everyone, and I certainly have my own issues with this approach, but I would be lying if I said both Night Alone and Midnight Shadows did not strike a chord with me. 

Both games have fantastic presentations that immediately set them apart from other entries in the genre. Due to their charming designs, it made it easy to fall in love with the characters, even if their eventual fates were somewhat predictable. Plus, while the exploration mechanics are a tad hit or miss, the improvements in Midnight Shadows and the brilliantly constructed terror in both Yomawari games makes up for the gameplay low points. That is not even taking into consideration the plenty of secrets and post-game content that Night Alone and Midnight Shadows offer, which add great incentives to replay both. 

Your enjoyment with Yomawari: The Long Night Collection is contingent on what you look for in the horror genre. This series frequently tackles extremely heavy topics that make the usual brutal deaths of other titles seem like child’s play. If you are a fan of J-horror experiences or are eager to have your heart strings tugged on relentlessly, then this is a must-play title. As for me, I am sure I will replay the collection once I have fully recovered from its emotional damages. 

Disclaimer: NIS America provided a PlayStation 5 copy of Yomawari: The Long Night Collection for review purposes. 

SUMMARY

Yomawari: The Long Night Collection is a collection of two devastating J-horror experiences. While its story can get a tad predictable and the exploration gameplay mechanics got stale very quickly, the brilliant presentation and characters help to offset any of my frustrations. Above all, the horror of both Yomawari: Night Alone and Midnight Shadows is extremely well done, and I will likely be thinking about these two games for a long time in spite of some of their low points.
Saras Rajpal
Saras Rajpal
Saras is a passionate writer, with a love for immersive sims, superhero games, and Persona. He graduated college with a Bachelor of Arts with a concentration in creative writing. He's been with Final Weapon since 2023.

Recommended Articles

Yomawari: The Long Night Collection is a collection of two devastating J-horror experiences. While its story can get a tad predictable and the exploration gameplay mechanics got stale very quickly, the brilliant presentation and characters help to offset any of my frustrations. Above all, the horror of both Yomawari: Night Alone and Midnight Shadows is extremely well done, and I will likely be thinking about these two games for a long time in spite of some of their low points. Yomawari: The Long Night Collection (PS5) Review - Charming and Cruel