Pikmin is such a weird, yet charming series. It’s not uncommon that you’ll keep hearing about how this is one of Shigeru Miyamoto’s passion projects. While I only got into the series with Pikmin 3 on the Wii U, to this day it remains an addictive game. And now, the latest installment of the series, Pikmin 4, makes its way with a Nintendo Switch 2 Edition upgrade, adding in some new features. But as always, we have to ask the question of whether we should spend $10 to upgrade this title, or if you should stick with the Nintendo Switch 1 version.
Back to PNF-404
The story of Pikmin 4 begins with a little planet known as PNF-404, where Captain Olimar crash-lands on the planet, with the S.S. Dolphin’s parts scattering around the planet. But after assembling some of them, he sends out an SOS signal, which gets picked up by the Rescue Corps. Unfortunately, their ship also crashes on the planet, leaving both them and Olimar stranded. This is where you come in. You have enlisted as the newest member of the Rescue Corps, so you hop onto the smaller ship called the S.S. Beagle, and fly to their rescue in PNF-404. It’s something about this planet that makes not one but two ships crash.
The story is rather humorous, and I like just how funny the dialogue between the Rescue Corps is. After each day, you’ll read a dialogue that features them chatting about what’s currently happening in the rescue mission, and you have so many good quotes from each of them, such as Dingo trying his hardest to excuse himself from assisting you, or Captain Shepherd’s rant about how we should all get along… except for the creatures on this planet. The castaways who you rescue also have their own unique personalities. Its placement on the timeline, though, is rather nebulous, as it appears to retcon a bunch of stuff from the Pikmin series, and unfortunately, even I have no idea.
Pikmin 4 also features a side story called Olimar’s Shipwreck Tale, which works as a sort of prequel where you’ll be collecting all of the S.S. Dolphin’s ship parts. It sounds simple, but you’re only given 15 days, and the clock itself appears to move faster than in the base game. In general, I would say Pikmin 4 will take you around 20 hours to beat, with maybe an additional 10 to 15 hours if you’d like to get 100% in everything.
The Art of Dandori
Now we get to the actual meat of the game, and that is the gameplay. You have a series of objectives to do, and there’s no strict order in which you need to do them. The first mission is to collect a material known as Sparklium, which will allow the Rescue Corps’ ship, the S.S. Shepherd, to obtain enough power to be able to leave the planet. The second main mission is to find Captain Olimar, as well as the dozens of castaways that have also crash-landed on PNF-404.
You’re not alone in this, however! You’re joined by cute little creatures known as Pikmin. They come in all sorts of colors, and each of them is great at specific tasks. For example, Red Pikmin are resistant to fire and have higher attack power, and Yellow Pikmin can be thrown much higher and resist electrical shocks. Pikmin 4 also goes a step further by introducing Ice Pikmin, whose icy bodies can freeze enemies and water bodies to allow you to cross. And you also have possibly the best companion, the Rescue Corps’ dog, Oatchi. He has so many abilities that you can teach, including one where he can seemingly gulp a gigantic treasure and just carry it to the ship like it’s nothing.
Trust me when I say that there is a lot of stuff you can do in this game. Genuinely, getting that 100% sound effect when you finish an area is hands down one of the most satisfying things to hear. My favorite task in the game has to be collecting all of the Treasures, because they all get assigned these quirky names and descriptions. To us, they may be just everyday objects, but to them, a D20 die is a “Go-With-the-Flow Totem”, and a calculator is called a “Number Jumper”.
A term you’ll often hear in this game is something called “Dandori”, which in Japanese, means “to arrange” or “to plan”. Any given area has Treasures to collect, caves to explore, and castaways to find, but each day has a time limit before you’re forced to go back to the base. Furthermore, scattered across the world are mysterious leafling creatures that will give you a Dandori Challenge, where instead of using your own Pikmin squad, you are by yourself with Oatchi and given a specific squad.
What I enjoy the most about the Pikmin series is how there are multiple solutions that you can apply to the tasks in the game, such as how you’re going to cross over a certain portion or which Pikmin can help you defeat a certain enemy. While there is a main objective to Pikmin 4, you can take as many Rescue Days as you want. Sadly, that does mean the main campaign doesn’t feature a leaderboard like Pikmin 3 had, but I’m not the type to speedrun games anyway, so I don’t think it’s that big of a loss, honestly.
No Recruit Fears the Night
I would be remiss if I did not mention the Night Expeditions. After all, in every Pikmin game up until now, it was always quite strict that you are not allowed to go out at night, because of the active creatures. But Pikmin 4 adds a new mode where you work with an army of another new type of Pikmin called the Glow Pikmin. The job is to guard this towering structure called the Lumiknoll until the sun rises, or once you’ve defeated all of the creatures around the area.
Some missions will even feature two Lumiknolls for you to defend. The best way I’ve found about doing this is to quickly get as many of the Glow Pikmin as you can, and have Oatchi defeat a few enemies that are lurking close, since even the slightest slip in your attention can cause the enemy to destroy the Lumiknoll, forcing you to start over. Some Glow Pikmin will even give you Glow Seeds, which can be used inside caves and during other Night Expeditions to help boost your numbers quicker. These Pikmin are sort of a replacement for the Bulbamin in Pikmin 2, in the sense that they’re resistant to nearly everything: Poison, electricity, water, fire, you name it.
Practice Your Dandori at the Academy
As the full game title implies, the main feature of the Nintendo Switch 2 Edition is something called Dandori Academy. Here, you’ll have a select number of missions that are cycled throughout each week, divided into Elementary, Advanced, and Graduate difficulties. And from Thursday to Sunday, you have an exam period, where you can attempt to get the highest possible score for medals. These medals will give you Dandori Points, which will in turn grant you rewards. It should be noted that unless you use a Redo Pass, which is obtained by practicing the exam stages, your score can only be registered once. The idea is that you practice and find the most optimal way throughout the week, and when Thursday arrives, and you have your strategy formed out, you attempt the exam for a high score.
These rewards, as far as I could tell, just consist of new stamps for the game’s Photo Mode, titles for your Dandori Status, and you can obtain in-game rewards for Pikmin Bloom. Honestly, I do think Dandori Academy is a mode that you can get bored of rather easily. My biggest gripe is that there’s no meaningful addition to the plot. The headmaster is the Leaf Sage, a character who you meet in the late game. But he doesn’t quite explain why this is an academy and its purpose in practicing Dandori. I also dislike how the game feels the need to cover half of the title screen to let you know an exam period is currently underway. I know this is meant to be the “add-on DLC” that Nintendo includes with almost every one of its Switch 2 Editions, but this one just feels… shoehorned in.
Sharper Graphics, But Same Frame Rate
When it comes to the graphics changes between the Nintendo Switch and Nintendo Switch 2 versions of the game, it appears Nintendo decided to make them a lot sharper and improve the loading times…but the frame rate stayed the same. This means the game is still running at 30 FPS, something the Nintendo Switch 2 Edition of Animal Crossing: New Horizons also did. My assumption is that the game’s logic may be tied to the framerate, but that’s just a guess. At least the textures don’t look like a smeary mess.
In fact, textures feel like one of the biggest improvements of the Switch 2 Edition. This is especially noticeable with the opening scenes whenever you get to a new area, or when you view the Treasure Catalogue. On Switch 1, it was rather common you’d see shimmering and some blurriness on some of the text and on metallic objects as they reflected in the game’s lighting. Loading times also greatly improved, though in my experience, I didn’t feel much of a difference.
And there are no mouse controls. But you can use the Switch 2’s microphone to give commands that will make the game respond accordingly. So how is it? Well, considering I wanted to turn it off after 10 minutes, that bodes well for it, doesn’t it? Because this is a very gimmicky feature. For one, it is VERY sensitive out of the box, to the point that whenever I said a word that had “This is” in it, the game sometimes picked it up as the command to “Dismiss” your Pikmin squad, and it’s very annoying when that happens. While you can tweak these settings in the menu, such as adding a noise cancellation filter, it kind of makes me wonder why they chose to add this over mouse controls, which would’ve been a better fit.
A Rather Lackluster Upgrade to A Phenomenal Masterpiece
I can’t deny that I feel very conflicted. I love Pikmin 4, and I really think it needs to be a must-play title. But this Nintendo Switch 2 upgrade of Pikmin 4 is unfortunately on the same level as Super Mario Party Jamboree‘s Nintendo Switch 2 Edition, sadly. Granted, it’s not a $20 upgrade, but still, you have to spend $10. So the main campaign and other stages really benefit from the better graphics and loading times.
Still, the addition of mic commands and the Dandori Academy mode feel superfluous and sometimes unnecessary. In a way, it makes me more strongly recommend that you get the game’s Switch 1 version and maybe, just maybe, consider the upgrade pack if you think the graphics are a bit lacking, even with the Handheld Mode Boost.
Disclaimer: Pikmin 4 Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy was reviewed on Nintendo Switch 2.