Recently, I started to get invested in the Yomawari franchise, an extremely dark J-horror series that balances charming visuals and exploration-based gameplay with a bleak tone and horrifying set pieces. After playing Yomawari: the Long Night Collection, which compiles the first two entries in the franchise, I was even more fascinated with both the series and the broader J-horror subgenre. At the same time, though, I was not a huge fan of the exploration gameplay which got stale fairly quickly, alongside the use of heavy subject matter for scenes built around shock value, making some story beats fairly predictable. So, when I learned of a third entry in the Yomawari franchise, I was hopeful that it would address all of my frustrations with the prior entries.
Yomawari: Lost in the Dark takes the formula of the PlayStation Vita games to a new platform. While the game initially released for PS4, Switch, and PC in 2022, the recent PlayStation 5 port has given me an excuse to jump into this third entry for the first time. I was curious how it would hold up to its predecessors, and if it would be able to evolve the storytelling and gameplay in meaningful ways. Sadly, while I did enjoy my time with Lost in the Dark, it mostly takes the same approach as prior games but to a far less compelling degree.
New Material but With the Same Punchline
Lost in the Dark begins with a premise that is initially a little bit different compared to prior entries. We start with a character that you can choose to name and even customize, though her default name is Yuzu. Yuzu’s journey starts in school, as she is relentlessly bullied and harassed by her classmates. Soon, their torment drives her to the building’s rooftop, and as she steps to the edge of a broken fence, she looks up into the sky and completely vanishes.
She soon awakes in a mysterious forest in which she encounters an equally mysterious older girl who tells her that the two of them have been cursed. While the older girl insists that Yuzu knows how to free them from their plight, Yuzu insists she has no memory of such a thing. So, after escaping the forest, Yuzu resolves to try and find her memories and hopefully break her curse in the process. The only catch is that her hometown has been overcome by ghosts of all shapes and sizes, all of whom are eager to cut Yuzu’s life short. It is up to you to avoid all these obstacles as you try and get to the bottom of this haunting mystery.
On the surface, the premise does have some fairly major differences from prior entries in the franchise. The addition of a customizable character, for instance, is a pretty major change. In addition, previous games in the series did not have a character that the protagonist plays off of as much as Kotori, the older girl from the opening. She is a consistent figure in the story that primarily shows up through memory sequences. Her role in the story is fantastic, and she quickly became my favorite character in the series. In practice, though, the broad strokes of Lost in the Dark‘s story are largely the same as prior entries in the Yomawari, even if it is presented in a different format.
For one, the themes of grief are pretty much identical to the rest of the Yomawari saga. On the one hand, there are plenty of horror franchises that explore the same themes in each entry, such as with Silent Hill. Yet, the way in which it explores its themes differ from game to game. Here, though, the format is virtually identical to every other game in the Yomawari franchise, down to the same plot twists throughout. Without getting into spoilers, the moment that Lost in the Dark introduced Mugi, Yuzu’s pet cat, I quickly and accurately guessed how the cat’s story would conclude. Unfortunately, the game is just as predictable as its predecessors in how it tackles its themes and characters.
Every other element of the story feels largely the same as prior entries. For example, the progression based around exploring locations that you encounter in memory sequences is pretty similar to how Yomawari: Midnight Shadows forces you to re-explore areas that you first saw in a short-lived sequence from the perspective of a secondary protagonist. The story progression of finding areas that are controlled by a specific ghost and having to lay them to rest bears a lot of commonalities with how Yomawari: Night Alone handles its chapters.
The few new ideas that are present in the story are admittedly interesting initially, before devolving at a later point. This is best scene with the aforementioned role of Kotori, and how the game actually has both a bad ending and a true ending. The process of getting the true ending is elaborate yet rewarding, and is clearly communicated via the bad ending. The problem is that it is in service of an ending that does not really feel satisfying, as it is once again very similar to the conclusion of Midnight Shadows. It made for a conclusion that was extremely frustrating, especially considering all the effort it took to get the true ending in the first place.
If you are stepping into Yomawari: Lost in the Dark as a standalone experience, these problems are relatively minor. After all, the characters and memory sequences are compelling enough on their own to be enjoyable regardless if you have played the prior games or not. However, considering this is a game that was marketed for a while as Yomawari 3 and is bundled together with the other two entries in the franchise, it is extremely infuriating that the game feels more like a reinterpretation of the first two Yomawari games, rather than a proper sequel.
Still, that is not to say that Yomawari: Lost in the Dark is completely derivative of its predecessors. Most of the new ideas can be seen in the gameplay mechanics and systems, as well as how it handles its level design. As a whole, the game is quite fun, even if it sometimes suffers from the same problems of derivation as the story.
The Best and Worst of the Yomawari Formula
Yomawari: Lost in the Dark is at its best when its trying out new ideas and evolving the formula. While the narrative falls short in that regard, the gameplay is far more satisfying in how it delivers on the inherent promise of a sequel. The first place you will notice this is in the mechanics. In prior Yomawari games, you are occasionally forced to hide in bushes and other locations in order to evade ghosts. Here, though, all you have to do is press the two triggers to close your eyes and slowly evade the enemies around you. It is a far more natural mechanic, and one that hinders the pacing far less compared to having to run to the nearest hiding spot at the first sight of a ghost.
The memory mechanic is also a great addition, even if it ends up being similar to how Midnight Shadows used its dual protagonists. It adds a tangible reward that you are working towards as you make your way through each area of the game, and adds further context to the relationship between Kotori and Yuzu. It’s made even better in the late game when you are given the chance to revisit those memories and see what details you missed, which eventually leads into the true ending.
By far and away the best new element in Lost in the Dark is how it handles the “level design.” Similarly to prior games, you have a vast world to explore that is rife with secrets and dangerous creatures. The memories you encounter as you explore are how you know which area to go to next. Where Lost in the Dark differs from Night Alone and Midnight Shadows are in these areas themselves. Each of them are uniquely designed and are a treat to explore due to the thrilling gameplay scenarios they present.
For example, in the late game you encounter a memory of Kotori near a beach before a ghostly boat arrives to drive both her and Yuzu away, causing the latter to drop an item that is vital to her journey to recover her memories. So, naturally, your first instinct is to visit the nearby beach, which you are led to by a mysterious specter. What you encounter when you arrive at the beach is the aforementioned ghostly boat, which has been overrun by water-themed ghosts. The only way to defeat them is with a camera that you recover from the specter, which you have to charge up in order to use. It is an incredibly tense sequence, that works because it forces you to change your play style. Above all, it is something that is unlike anything I have experienced in prior entries.
There are still some elements of Lost in the Dark that are similar to prior entries, of course. Some of these elements are much appreciated, such as the returning presentation. The visual style of the Yomawari series is one of its greatest strengths, and while I wish there were a few more adjustments to the presentation to make it look a little more new, it still looks gorgeous. It shines in how it manages to present characters that are both adorable, as well as monsters that look absolutely terrifying.
Consequently, however, some of the aforementioned areas that you explore do look eerily similar to their predecessors. One such example is the school, which looks borderline identical to the school section from Night Alone. Plus, since the gameplay has the same foundation as the rest of the Yomawari series, it does mean it suffers from the same problems as its predecessors. Namely, while the world of Lost in the Dark is more rich, the core loop of backtracking through the same areas ad nauseam can get pretty stale, especially when combined with the boss fights. These boss fights, while visually impressive, are quite frustrating in how they are built around design choices that are completely antithetical to everything the game has taught you about its mechanics thus far.
Still, these frustrations did not change the fact that the fun I managed to derive from Yomawari: Lost in the Dark. Simultaneously, though, they are not enough to completely fix my other major issues with the overall experience.
Heartbreaking
What do you expect when you pick up a sequel to a game when you really enjoy? As a fan, do you expect a follow-up that largely follows the same broad strokes of its predecessor? Or are you hoping for one that evolves the gameplay and storytelling in new and exciting ways, making for a game that feels both familiar and fresh at the same time? When I first played the two inaugural entries in the Yomawari franchise, I had a good time with both, yet I came away wanting more. I hoped that a third entry would address my prior frustrations, while also delivering a game that stayed true to the Yomawari name. Instead, what I got was a game that feels more like a remake than a sequel.
There are certainly some bright spots of Yomawari: Lost in the Dark. The characters are a fantastic upgrade due to their role in the story, and the new level design and gameplay sequences are the exact breath of fresh air that I hoped for. However, the story largely covers the same themes and plot twists as both Yomawari: Night Alone and Midnight Shadows, almost to a t. This also applies to the gameplay, which is built off of the same formula as its predecessors, and falls victim to the same stale design choices that plagued them.
Overall, while I may have had fun with Yomawari: Lost in the Dark, I cannot say I was satisfied by it. If you are jumping into the game as a standalone experience, then perhaps you may find it to be a great J-horror experience on its own merits. However, if you are treating it as the third entry it was designed to be, then this is is easily the worst entry in the franchise. It may not be bad, but I definitely have no desire to return to it anytime soon compared to the first two Yomawari games.
Disclaimer: NIS America provided a PlayStation 5 copy of Yomawari: Lost in the Dark for review purposes.